New Serial Killer Research Sheds Light on Violent Sexual Fantasies
What Might It Teach Us About Rex Heuermann?
"Fantasy is hardly an escape from reality. It's a way of understanding it." - Lloyd Alexander, the author of this quote and over forty fantasy novels for children and young adults, understood that fantasy is not merely a means of escaping reality but a tool for comprehending it. For many serial killers, fantasies play a unique role. They not only fester in darkness long before bursting into murder; they are often the energy that fuels it.
But how? When? And why? A groundbreaking 2023 study* published in the Journal of Threat Assessment and Management sheds new light on the disturbing role that violent sexual fantasies play in the psyches of sexually motivated serial murderers. Conducting in-depth interviews with twenty convicted serial killers, they explored the prevalence, nature, and progression of their violent sexual fantasies to see how they mapped onto their homicidal crimes. In this article, we'll take a look at what they found and see how their findings compare to what we know about alleged Long Island serial killer Rex Heuermann.
Rex Heuermann booking photo
The Onset and Duration of Violent Fantasies
One of the most striking findings of the 2023 study was the remarkably early onset and prolonged duration of violent fantasies among the serial killers interviewed. On average, participants reported that their violent fantasies began during childhood or adolescence, with some indicating that they could trace their dark imaginings back to as early as five or six years old.
These early fantasies often arose in the context of childhood trauma, such as exposure to domestic violence, sexual abuse, or severe neglect. Many participants described growing up in chaotic, unstable environments where violence was normalized or even celebrated. For some, these early experiences of powerlessness and victimization seemed to plant the seeds of their later obsessions with control and domination. For example, one participant described growing up in a household where his father regularly beat his mother and how this exposure to violence shaped his later fantasies of power and control over women.
Shockingly, the study found that the average duration of serial killers' violent fantasies before they committed their first murder was 8.2 years. This extended period of mental rehearsal highlights the fact that serial murder is rarely a spontaneous or impulsive act but rather the culmination of a longstanding preoccupation with violence and control.
During these years of fantasy development, the killers reported that their imaginings became increasingly elaborate and detailed. They would spend countless hours mentally rehearsing their desired crimes, refining every aspect from the selection of victims to the methods of torture and disposal of bodies. Many described this process as a form of "mental practice" that allowed them to perfect their planned actions and anticipate potential obstacles.
The Nature and Triggers of Violent Sexual Fantasies
The study also delved into the specific content and triggers of the serial killers' violent fantasies. While the details varied among participants, several common themes emerged.
Many of the fantasies centered around extreme acts of sexual violence, torture, and degradation inflicted upon specific types of victims, often women or children. The killers frequently described elaborate scenarios involving kidnapping, restraint, and sadistic rituals that would allow them to exert complete control over their victims. These fantasies were often fueled by a deep-seated rage towards women or society in general, with the imagined violence serving as a means of retribution or asserting dominance.
Disturbingly, some participants reported that consuming violent pornography played a significant role in shaping and intensifying their fantasies. They described seeking out increasingly extreme content that mirrored their own dark imaginings, using it as a form of validation and stimulation. However, it's crucial to note that not all individuals who consume violent pornography go on to commit violent crimes, and the causal link between such content and real-world violence remains a matter of ongoing research and debate.
Another common trigger for violent fantasies among serial killers was a sense of social isolation and rejection. Many participants reported feeling like outcasts or misfits throughout their lives, struggling to form healthy relationships and often harboring deep resentment towards those whom they perceived as having rejected or wronged them. In their fantasies, they could exact revenge upon these individuals or surrogates, asserting a sense of power and control that eluded them in reality.
The study also found that serial killers' fantasies often intensified during times of heightened stress or life transitions. Losing a job, ending a relationship, or experiencing some other form of perceived failure or humiliation seemed to act as a catalyst, propelling the killers deeper into their violent imaginings. Some participants described their fantasies as a form of escapism or coping mechanism during these difficult periods, a way to retreat into a world where they held ultimate power and control.
When asked to explain or justify their violent fantasies, the serial killers offered a range of rationalizations. Some described their fantasies as a way to cope with past traumas or to regain a sense of power and control in their lives. Others framed their fantasies as a form of "revenge" against a society that had rejected or marginalized them.
However, the researchers noted that these explanations often seemed superficial or self-serving and that the serial killers rarely displayed genuine insight into the harmful and destructive nature of their fantasies. Many of the participants seemed to view their fantasies as a normal or inevitable part of their identity rather than as a distorted and dangerous preoccupation.
The Transition from Fantasy to Reality
Research has taught us that it is common for adults to have unusual - even violent - sexual fantasies. Most of us never consider acting on them. And among those who do, the vast majority find a socially acceptable way to express themselves, whether it's involvement in a consensual BDSM relationship or exploration of a mutual fetish.
One of the most chilling aspects of the 2023 study was its exploration of how serial killers transitioned from fantasizing about murder to committing it. The participants described a gradual escalation of violence, often beginning with "rehearsal" activities that mirrored elements of their fantasies.
These activities could include stalking potential victims, acquiring weapons or restraints, visiting remote locations that could serve as potential dump sites, or even practicing their planned methods of torture on animals. The killers reported that these preparatory behaviors served as a way to test the feasibility of their fantasies and build their confidence to act on them.
In some cases, the transition from fantasy to murder was triggered by a specific event or stressor, such as a perceived slight or rejection that echoed earlier traumas. One participant, for example, described how being fired from his job by a female supervisor spurred him to act on his long-held fantasies of sexually mutilating women in positions of power. However, even in these seemingly spontaneous instances, the study found that years of meticulous planning and mental rehearsal typically preceded the murders.
Alarmingly, the study also revealed that many of the serial killers experienced a sense of anticlimax or dissatisfaction after committing their first murder. The reality of the act often failed to live up to the expectations set by their elaborate fantasies, leading them to seek out new victims to recapture that elusive sense of fulfillment. This finding underscores the compulsive, addictive nature of serial murder for many perpetrators.
The Rex Heuermann Case: How Does He Compare?
I imagine anyone reading this article is familiar with Rex Heuermann, the sixty-year-old architect from Massapequa Park, New York, who was arrested on July 13, 2023, in connection with the long-unsolved Gilgo Beach murders. He is charged with the murders of four young women: Melissa Barthelemy, Megan Waterman, Amber Lynn Costello, and Maureen Brainard-Barnes. Prosecutors have not ruled out Heuermann's involvement in the deaths of the other victims found in the area, and the investigation is ongoing.
Rex Heuermann has pleaded not guilty to all charges. He certainly isn't conducting media interviews or publicly discussing his sexual interests. However, investigators have uncovered a treasure trove of internet searches that give us a peak into what turns him on. And what they've found is both diverse and disturbing.
Heurmann's online history reportedly paints a chilling picture of a man consumed by violent and sadistic sexual fantasies. This picture aligns with the 2023 study's overall findings on the role of violent fantasies in serial murderers. From what we know so far, Heuermann's internet searches allegedly included several disturbing themes and keywords:
Specific pornographic content related to violence against women, including searches for terms like "torture," "abuse", and "rape." These searches suggest a fixation on sexual content involving the domination, control, and degradation of female victims.
Searches related to the dismemberment and disposal of human remains, including terms like "butchering" and "dissection," suggest a morbid fascination with the logistics of committing and concealing violent crimes.
Searches related to sex workers and the sex trade, including terms like "escort," "prostitute," and specific locations known for prostitution. Given that many of the Gilgo Beach victims were believed to be sex workers, this could suggest a targeted interest in this vulnerable population.
Specific searches related to the Gilgo Beach case itself, including the names of some of the known victims and terms related to the investigation, indicate a level of detailed knowledge about the case that goes beyond casual interest.
When analyzing these alleged searches through the lens of academic research on serial killers, several key themes emerge:
The fixation on violent, misogynistic pornography aligns with theories about the role of sexual fantasy in reinforcing and normalizing violent impulses. Some studies have suggested that a subset of serial killers use pornography to rehearse and validate their fantasies of control and domination over victims.
The interest in the logistics of body disposal and evidence concealment points to a level of planning and premeditation that is common among organized serial killers. This type of offender often spends a great deal of time mentally rehearsing and refining their crimes before acting on them.
The targeted focus on sex workers suggests a perpetrator who is seeking out victims who are marginalized, vulnerable, and less likely to be missed fits with the typical victim profile in many serial murder cases.
While Heuerman's specific searches related to the Gilgo Beach investigation likely have a practical motive – avoiding capture – it may also be a way for him to relive and take pride in his alleged crimes. Some serial killers are known to closely follow media coverage of their cases as a way to fuel their ego and sense of power.
Of course, disturbing internet searches alone do not prove an individual's guilt, and not everyone who consumes violent or worrisome content goes on to commit real-world crimes. However, in the context of the other evidence that has emerged in the Heuermann case, these alleged search patterns do seem to paint a picture of someone with a longstanding and detailed fantasy life involving sexual exploitation and violence against women - particularly those in high-risk populations like sex workers.
Real World Implications
Shedding light on the early warning signs and triggers associated with the development of violent sexual fantasies provides us with valuable guidance for designing targeted intervention strategies. Mental health professionals working with individuals who have experienced severe childhood trauma or exhibited signs of social isolation and rage towards women may be better equipped to identify and address nascent violent fantasies before they escalate into real-world behavior.
Law enforcement agencies may be able to use the study's insights to refine their criminal profiling techniques and prioritize suspects who fit the patterns of fantasy development and rehearsal behavior identified in the research. By recognizing the long-term trajectory and red flags associated with these fantasies, investigators may be better positioned to intervene before a potential killer can claim their first victim.
However, the study also highlights the immense challenges inherent in predicting and preventing serial murder based on fantasy alone. Many individuals who harbor violent fantasies or consume extreme pornographic content never go on to commit real-world crimes, and the line between "normal" dark thoughts and genuine homicidal intent can be blurry. As such, any preventative strategies must be carefully designed to avoid infringing on individual liberties or stigmatizing mental health issues.
Additionally, the study's reliance on self-reporting from a relatively small sample of incarcerated serial killers presents some limitations. The participants may have distorted or misrepresented their experiences to present themselves in a particular light or to align with cultural narratives about serial murder. Future research could benefit from incorporating more diverse methodologies, such as neuroimaging or longitudinal studies, to provide a more comprehensive understanding of the role of fantasy in serial murder.
Conclusion
While the study's findings are undeniably disturbing, they also offer a glimmer of hope. By identifying the critical warning signs and risk factors associated with the development of violent sexual fantasies, we may be able to intervene earlier and more effectively to prevent these dark imaginings from spilling over into real-world violence. It's a weighty responsibility that falls on the shoulders of mental health professionals, law enforcement agencies, and society as a whole - but one that we must bear if we hope to build a safer, more just world.
References:
* Davis, M., et al. (2023). The role of fantasy and mental rehearsal in the planning and execution of serial murders. Journal of Threat Assessment and Management, 10(1), 23-35.
Thanks for reading this issue of The Mind Detective. Please share with your true-crime-following friends and family. If there’s a case you’d like me to cover, please let me know.