"I Watch Dateline Every Night and He Could Do Something Like That to Me"

The Three-Year Vanishing of Dee Warner

Dee Ann Warner did not show up for Sunday breakfast on April 25, 2021. Her grown daughter Rikkell pulled into the driveway of the Munger Road farmhouse at 9:30 that morning, the way she did most Sundays, expecting to eat with her mother and plan the week.

The cars were in the driveway. The front door was unlocked. The nine-year-old who normally slept in her mother’s bed was at a friend’s house. The house was empty. By the time Dee’s family understood what had actually happened, Dee had been gone for three years and almost four months.

Dee Ann Hardy Warner was fifty-two when she went missing from her home.

Dee was Raynor and Wanda Hardy’s daughter, born July 29, 1968, into a Lenawee County farming family that had been working the same southern Michigan ground for five generations. Tipton, where the Hardys farmed, is a town of about two thousand people, sixty miles southwest of Detroit.

Both of Dee’s parents were gone. Her older brother Gregg was her closest sibling and her measuring stick. Gregg’s son Parker, Dee’s nephew, put it this way: “She had a major drive to be successful. Her brother’s been successful over the years, and she wanted to follow right in his path, if not beat him. It was always a competition of who could get there first.” She wanted to win, and she didn’t pretend otherwise.

By April of 2021, Dee was 52. She had five children and seven grandchildren. She had been a 4-H leader and mentor in Lenawee County for years and was still active in the program. She ran three businesses with her second husband out of a property at the corner of Munger Road and Carson Highway, near Tecumseh. Friends called her a social butterfly. Gregg called her a scrapper.

At the close of Dale Warner’s preliminary hearing in May 2024, Judge Anna Frushour summed up Dee from the bench: “Dee Warner was a woman with a big heart and a temper. She cared for her children and grandchildren, and employees.” Nothing in the evidence, the judge said, suggested Dee would have walked away from any of them.

Asked what his sister would have done if she had decided to leave her marriage on her own terms, Gregg didn’t pause: “Her demeanor would more than likely be to set the house on fire on her way out, if she were leaving.”

That was the woman who did not come to breakfast.

A Wife-Swap and an Empire

Dee’s first husband was Tim Bock. Their four children carried his surname: Amber, T.J., Zack, and Rikkell.

Dale Warner had been farming in Lenawee County his whole adult life. His first wife was Julie. They had a son, Jaron, and divorced in 2003.

After both marriages ended, the four adults reshuffled. Tim Bock married Julie. Dale Warner began dating Dee. Eventually, they married, too. Two couples who knew each other had become two new couples, sharing the same children across the same small county.

“It was hard on the kids because of the fights,” Parker Hardy said in court years later. “When you have this ‘wife swap’ situation, it just got to be ‘he, she, they, theirs,’ and it was really hard on the kids. I remember, especially during fair time, you had both sets of kids growing up in 4-H, and everybody eventually had to meet up at the fair to see the kids’ show. Both sides were extremely supportive of their kids, but it was very socially uncomfortable.”

When CBS’s 48 Hours later asked Gregg whether the second marriage had been a love match, his answer was no.

Dee and Dale started their first business together in 2005 and married the next year. Their daughter Angalena was born in 2011. By then, they were running three businesses out of the property on Munger Road and the surrounding farms: a fifteen-hundred-acre farm, a chemical and fertilizer operation that sold seed and crop inputs, and the trucking company. The trucking company was Dee’s. By 2021, it had become the most successful of the three.

What the marriage offered Dee, Parker would later say in court, was a chance at empire building. Dee brought the operational instincts. Dale brought the farm, the equipment, the land base, and a name that had been part of agriculture in Lenawee County for decades. Dee couldn’t walk out without unwinding all of it. She would have to take the businesses apart to get free.

Inside the Marriage

The trucking company kept Dee on the phone all day, which meant she talked to a lot of people. Stephanie Voelkle, who worked for her, said Dee was tough and generous and didn’t suffer fools. Amy Alexander, who was dating Dale’s brother Bill, talked to Dee almost daily. Stacey Brodie was Dee’s massage therapist for years. Rikkell came by the Munger Road house most days. Zack called every day, sometimes more than once.

Stacey saw bruises on her client’s body for years. At one point, Dale pushed Dee into a dresser hard enough that the incident later became part of the prosecution’s case.

Amber, Dee’s oldest daughter, would later testify that her mother had talked about leaving Dale countless times. Rikkell saw it from closer in. She would come over and find her mother visibly relaxed when Dale wasn’t in the house, then watch her go quiet when he came home. Dustin Lolley, Rikkell’s boyfriend, noticed the same pattern. He also heard Dale make degrading comments about Dee’s cooking and her clothing within her earshot.

Dee drove two vehicles. Dale tracked both. Beginning in January 2019, he used a phone app linked to her Cadillac Escalade’s onboard service to check her location. Prosecutors documented more than 2,100 location checks between January 2019 and April 2021.

In July 2020, when Dee’s Hummer was in for service, the mechanic found a separate, physical GPS tracker. Dustin Lolley later testified that Dale had asked an employee to buy and install it. Dee kept the SD card. Dustin testified that she was very angry about it.

Two and a half checks a day. Every day. For twenty-seven months.

Dee was building an exit. She had begun looking at a lakehouse down the road from the Munger Road property. She had moved what money she could. She had told the people closest to her that she was going to leave.

Billy Little Jr., the family’s investigative attorney, put it directly at a press conference. “Dee definitely had an escape plan for that marriage. She knew that this was not ending well. Part of her escape plan was to purchase a lakehouse, just down the road.”

By early 2021, Dee was telling her oldest daughter that she was going to sell the trucking business and divorce Dale. She had not told Dale yet. She was telling her daughters, her son, her closest friends.

She also told Rikkell something else. Rikkell repeated it under oath at the May 2024 preliminary hearing in Lenawee County District Court, with Dale sitting in the courtroom.

“One of the last things that my mom said to me was, ‘I watch Dateline like every night and he could do something like that to me.’”

By April of 2021, Angalena was nine years old. Dee had four grown children, three businesses, and a brother two miles away who would have walked through fire for her. She had a Hummer she now knew was bugged. She had a husband who checked her location an average of 2.5 times a day. She had a lakehouse she was looking at and a divorce conversation she had not yet had.

She had decided, at 52, to take her life back.

She had a week left.

Saturday

Saturday, April 24, 2021, was the day Dee decided on. She had told the people closest to her what she was going to do. She had told them she was going to sit her husband down that night and tell him the marriage was over. She was going to sell the trucking business. She was going to leave.

By Saturday afternoon, the people closest to Dee were alarmed by how she looked.

Amber stopped by and was alarmed enough by what she saw to call Rikkell, which she normally didn’t do.

Rikkell saw Dee a few hours later, around four or five in the afternoon, at the Munger Road house. She testified at trial that her mother looked like “a shell of herself.” Rikkell sat with her for a while. Dee told her, again, what she was planning to do that night. She said she was going to tell Dale she wanted a divorce. She said she was going to sell the trucking business. Rikkell had heard the part about the divorce before. The selling-the-business part was new.

Around seven that evening, Amy Alexander arrived at the house. Amy and Dee had been close for about a decade, through Dale’s brother Bill and because the two women genuinely liked each other. Earlier that day, Amy had suggested that Angalena stay overnight. The nine-year-old should not be there when her parents had the conversation Dee was about to have. Dee agreed. Amy picked Angalena up around seven.

Amy talked to Dee one more time that night. The call ended at 7:42 p.m.

Rikkell texted her mother around nine. Dee did not answer. That was unusual but not alarming, given the night Dee was about to have.

Late that night, Rikkell drove past her mother’s house on her way home. The lights were on. The Hummer was parked where it normally wasn’t. Rikkell noticed both things and kept driving.

Zack, Dee’s son, talked to her around seven or eight that evening. He and his mother spoke every day, sometimes multiple times. He testified later that the only time she ever didn’t respond to him was when she went missing.

At 7:42 on Saturday evening, April 24, 2021, Amy Alexander hung up the phone with her friend. Nobody who loved Dee Warner ever spoke to her again.

Sunday

Sunday morning at the Hardy and Bock houses meant breakfast. Not always at the same place, not always at the same hour, but reliable enough that Dee’s absence was out of character.

Rikkell and Dee had plans for that day. Rikkell was remodeling her house, and her mother had been helping. They would eat together at Munger Road, then figure out the week: what Rikkell needed, what Dee could pick up, what would get done before the next Sunday.

On April 25, 2021, Rikkell was due at 9:30. Her boyfriend, Dustin, was with her. They pulled in around 9:30. The door was unlocked, which was not unusual on a working farm. Rikkell let herself in.

The house was empty.

Dee’s Hummer was outside, still out of its normal parking place. The JCB front-loader, a piece of heavy equipment usually parked elsewhere on the property, was in the spot where the Hummer normally parked. Rikkell noticed it without yet understanding what she was noticing.

Rikkell walked through the house calling for her mother. The bedroom was empty. The living room, where Dale would later tell investigators he had last seen Dee asleep on the couch, was empty. Dee didn’t answer her phone. Rikkell tried calling again. Nothing.

Rikkell and Dustin drove to the farm office and then back to the house. They called Zack. They called Amber. They called T.J. Nobody had heard from Dee that morning. Within an hour, the four Bock children were converging on the property and the surrounding farms. They checked barns. They checked the spray barn. They checked Dale’s brother Bill’s place. They drove the perimeter. They called Uncle Gregg.

Angalena was still at Amy Alexander’s house. Nobody had come to pick her up.

Zack went to the office and pulled up the security camera feeds, which covered the house and the work areas. He sat down to look through the footage from earlier that morning. He did not see his mother. He saw Dale. He saw Dale moving around the property in the early hours of the morning, doing things Zack could not yet read.

Dale called Rikkell. He asked if she had heard from her mother. He told her he had gone out at six to spray, and Dee had been asleep on the living room couch when he did. He said the two of them had argued the night before, but he had rubbed her shoulders and they had been fine.

Rikkell drove to where Dale was. He met her in the bedroom of the Munger Road house. He told her Dee had been leaving in the middle of the night and that she had pills hidden around the house. He told her Dee had left her wedding ring on the desk in the office.

Then Dale walked her into the kitchen. He held the wedding ring in his hand. He said, “Oh, fuck.”

He said, “Everything I’ve worked for is gone.”

He recited his and Dee’s wedding vows aloud.

By late morning, the Bock children had stopped pretending this was a normal Sunday. Gregg got the call. By the afternoon, much of the Hardy and Bock side of the family was at the Munger Road property, calling everyone who knew Dee and putting together a timeline of where she had been. Amy Alexander still had Angalena. The 4-H families were beginning to hear. The trucking company employees were beginning to hear.

The family called the Lenawee County Sheriff’s Office around midday. A deputy was dispatched.

By the time the deputy’s car pulled into the driveway on Munger Road that afternoon, the Hardy and Bock family had already concluded that the rest of Lenawee County would take much longer to reach.

Dee had not left.

“I’m Not Real Concerned”

Deputy Austin Hall of the Lenawee County Sheriff’s Office arrived at the Munger Road property on the afternoon of April 25, 2021. He was wearing a body camera. The footage from that camera would be played in courtrooms three times: at the September 2023 declaration-of-death hearing, at the May 2024 preliminary hearing, and again in front of the jury at trial in February 2026.

What the camera recorded was a man whose wife had been missing since the night before. His nine-year-old daughter was still at a friend’s house, where Amy Alexander had picked her up Saturday evening, and where nobody had come to retrieve her.

Dale walked the deputy through the house. He showed him what was missing. A hair curler. A hairdryer. A makeup bag. He told the deputy he didn't know if Dee was missing or had just left, that she often left for days. He told him Dee had been taking prescription painkillers for a migraine she'd developed the night before. He told the deputy he had found her wedding ring on the desk in the farm office, which he offered, on camera, as evidence that his wife had left him voluntarily.

The deputy asked how the previous night had been between them. Dale rated the fight a five out of ten. He said, “We’ve had a lot worse fights. I don’t get it.”

He said, “I should have fucking stayed home.”

The deputy asked if he was worried.

Dale said, “I’m not real concerned.”

He said this on camera, hours after his wife had vanished, with their daughter still uncollected at a friend’s house, with Dee’s grown children searching the property and calling everyone they could think of.

Later in the same set of interviews, with Detective Kevin Greca of the Lenawee County Sheriff’s Office, Dale was asked to remove his clothes so that any scratches or marks could be photographed. He had no visible injuries, and Greca documented his condition with photos. Dale was cooperative throughout. He consented to searches of the property and his electronic devices. He gave investigators contacts and suggestions. He stayed in the conversation.

He also told investigators things that contradicted each other. He said Dee had moved her Hummer from its usual parking spot. He also said he had returned to the house at seven in the morning in the front-end loader and parked it where the Hummer normally was, with Dee asleep on the living room couch when he came in. Both could not be true. If Dee was asleep on the couch when he parked the JCB in her parking spot, she could not have been the one who moved the Hummer.

Lenawee County Prosecutor Jacqueline Wyse would later walk a jury through this contradiction in her closing arguments. “Those two things cannot be true at the same time,” she told the jury.

The deputy left the property that afternoon. Dale stayed. The Bock children stayed. Gregg stayed. Angalena was eventually picked up. Sunday turned into night.

By Monday morning, the Hardy and Bock family had spent 24 hours reaching the same conclusion: the husband in the body-camera footage was not behaving like a man whose wife had walked out. The man holding the wedding ring in the kitchen that morning was not behaving like a man who expected his wife to come home.

Gregg later told a reporter that the family had felt, almost from the first hours, that they were being asked to accept a story that did not match the woman they knew. He used a word for it that stuck. He called it concocted.

What the family could not yet see was that the story they were being asked to accept was about to become the Lenawee County Sheriff’s Office’s working theory for 16 months. The deputies who took the report on April 25 did not log the case as a homicide. The sheriff’s office did not treat the property as a crime scene. The investigators did not, in those critical first hours, do the kinds of things investigators do when they believe a person has been killed.

They treated it as a missing-person case.

What Walking Away Actually Looks Like

People do walk away from their lives. Not often, but it happens. When it does, it has a recognizable shape.

Researchers have studied missing-person cases for behavioral patterns. The best empirical work, looking at 362 adult missing-person cases handled by Police Scotland, found three.

The first, they called dysfunctional; 18 percent of cases, driven by mental illness, substance dependence, or psychiatric crisis. The second was called unintentional; 41 percent, where the person didn’t mean to be missing. They got hurt. They got lost. They had an accident.

The third was called escape. The smallest group, about 11 percent. The person decided to leave their life voluntarily and disappear. They walked away from a stressor, a marriage, a debt, an unbearable situation, and they did it on their own terms.

People who escape do recognizable things. They go to places they associate with safety. They sleep on couches, sleep in their cars, or move in with someone they trust. They take the essentials: phone, money, ID, a few clothes. They sometimes leave notes; they sometimes don’t. They avoid police but almost always resurface in ways their old life can absorb. A bank withdrawal. A call to a sibling six months later. A social media login from a different state.

The drivers are interpersonal. Relationship breakdown. Financial stress. Abuse. The desire to escape something the person could not survive staying inside.

Dee Warner did not fit any part of this pattern.

Her purse was found at the house. Her phone went silent at the property and never moved again. Her wallet stayed. Her ID stayed. Her shoes and socks stayed. Her clothes were in her closet. The Hummer was in the driveway, parked in the wrong place. Her wedding ring was on the desk.

She did not go somewhere safe. There was no contact with a sibling. There was no call to a friend. There was no withdrawal from a bank. There was no login on any account. The cell signal stopped at the house and never resumed anywhere else. The five categories investigators eventually documented as empty (financial activity, digital activity, official records, relational contact, physical possessions) produced nothing until Dee’s body was found.

She did not leave Angalena. Dee had moved her nine-year-old to a friend’s house specifically so the child would not be there for the conversation. The mother who had built her last twelve years around Angalena did not leave her in someone else’s living room and disappear into a different identity.

Most missing people come home. The ones who don't are usually found dead from accidents, mental-health crises, or other unintentional causes. A study of 615 fatal missing-person cases across 22 English and Welsh police forces put fatal outcomes at roughly one in 358 missing-person incidents. Homicide is the rarest of those outcomes.

In practice, that means a sheriff’s office in a county of 99,000 people, faced with a report of a missing 52-year-old woman whose husband is calmly explaining that she has run away with a secret phone, will almost always be looking at a case that resolves itself.

Almost always.

A Concocted Story

Gregg Hardy spoke at a vigil for Dee at his farm on November 13, 2021, almost seven months after his sister vanished. Dozens of people gathered at the barn at the corner of Wisner Highway and Munger Road. Yard signs reading Justice for Dee lined the property. An image of Dee was displayed inside the barn.

He took the microphone and read his opinion about Dale’s version of events from a written statement.

“Quite frankly, I consider it a concocted story. It is my opinion that very valuable time was lost while the authorities pursued the unlikely story that Dee left without any car, or even a note to a family member, without saying goodbye, which would not be her character at all, as I am sure most of you know.”

He said it had been extremely frustrating trying to work with detectives and the Sheriff’s Office, and that the lack of meaningful communication, urgency, and accountability had been unacceptable. The family, he said, had been asked for seven months to believe a story that did not fit the woman they knew.

For the first six months, the Lenawee County Sheriff's Office treated Dee's disappearance as a missing-person case. The deputies who responded on April 25 filed a report, and detectives followed up by interviewing Dale twice. No one secured the property as a crime scene. No one pulled the security cameras. No one requested preservation letters from cell carriers or cloud providers. This is the wait-and-see treatment the FBI's Behavioral Analysis Unit names as the dominant failure mode in disappearances that turn out to be killings — investigators default to waiting, and the electronic data requests that should go out within the first 72 hours often don't.

A search of the Munger Road property finally took place on October 11 and 12, 2021, almost six months after Dee disappeared. Lenawee County deputies coordinated it with assistance from the FBI, the Michigan State Police, the Michigan Department of Natural Resources, the Washtenaw County Sheriff’s Office, and a volunteer K-9 search-and-rescue unit out of Flint. They walked the fields. They worked the outbuildings. They used ground-penetrating radar. They did not find Dee. The search ended after two days.

Sheriff Troy Bevier would later acknowledge that his department had lacked the resources for a case of this complexity, and would praise the Michigan State Police for the work that followed. The family was not getting that acknowledgment in 2021. They were watching the first window, the one where evidence is still recoverable, close.

The Hardy and Bock family stopped waiting.

Gregg and his wife, Shelley, began organizing. The family launched a Facebook page, Justice for Dee. By 2024, it would have more than 33,000 followers. They put yard signs out on Wisner Highway, then along M-50, then across Lenawee County. The signs were everywhere. A reporter from Detroit drove down for the first time and described seeing them lined up “as far as the eye can see on a country road.”

The family hired a private investigator. Then they hired Billy Little Jr., a former federal prosecutor who specialized in cold cases and complex investigations. Gregg later told a reporter he spent hundreds of thousands of dollars of his own money on the search. Billy Little ran his own parallel investigation, interviewed witnesses, and pushed the family’s evidence forward. At a press conference at Hardy Farms in May 2022, with Gregg and Shelley standing beside him, Little told reporters: “He will be arrested. There’s no question about that. There will be an end to this, whether it’s today, tomorrow, or a month from now.”

Investigation Discovery’s Disappeared aired an episode about Dee in October 2022, titled “Vanished in the Heartland.” NBC’s Dateline: Missing in America podcast featured the case. Retired homicide detective Chris McDonough interviewed Billy Little on his podcast The Interview Room. Each piece of national coverage sent another wave of attention back to Lenawee County, and another wave of pressure on the agencies that had been working the case for the first 16 months.

In August 2022, Sheriff Bevier transferred the case to the Michigan State Police.

The transfer was announced at a rally for Dee. The MSP Major Crimes Unit, with FBI assistance, took over. Detective Lieutenant Daniel Drewyor was assigned as lead.

He started over.

He pulled what could still be pulled. He did the witness interviews that should have happened in May 2021. He pulled cell-tower data, location-check records, financial activity, and electronic devices. He built the case that the Lenawee County Sheriff’s Office had not built.

Where’s the Proof of Life?

In 1660, an elderly steward named William Harrison left his home in the Cotswold market town of Chipping Campden, Gloucestershire, on a two-mile walk to collect rents in the village of Charingworth. He never came home. His hat was found slashed and his neckcloth bloodstained on the road. His servant, John Perry, told a story that shifted under questioning, naming his mother, Joan, and his brother, Richard, as accomplices. The body was never found. All three Perrys were tried, convicted, and hanged in 1661.

Two years later, William Harrison returned to England by ship from Lisbon, with a long and improbable story about having been abducted, sold into slavery in the Ottoman Empire, and eventually escaping.

The Campden Wonder became the cautionary folk principle behind centuries of English and American judicial conservatism about murder convictions without a body. The reasoning was intuitive: if you cannot produce the dead person, you cannot rule out the possibility that the dead person is alive somewhere. And if the dead person turns out to be alive, you have hanged three people for a murder that did not happen.

The doctrine of corpus delicti grew out of that worry. The phrase translates roughly to “the body of the crime,” but in legal practice, it has never required an actual body. It requires proof that a crime was committed and that the defendant committed it.

California settled the modern American framework in 1959 in People v. Scott, when the Court of Appeals held that circumstantial evidence, if sufficient to exclude every other reasonable hypothesis, can establish that the person is dead, that the death was the result of a criminal act, and that the defendant is the person responsible. Former federal prosecutor Tad DiBiase, who tracks no-body cases, notes that there have been 576 no-body homicide trials in American history with a conviction rate of roughly 87 percent. The higher success rate for no-body cases is likely because prosecutors only take the strongest ones to trial.

A homicide case with a body asks: how did this person die, and who killed them? A no-body case has to answer those questions plus one more: how do we know the person is dead at all? With no corpse, the prosecutor proves death indirectly by demonstrating the absence of life. If a person is alive, they leave traces. The state's job in a no-body case is to show that the missing person has stopped leaving traces in every category where a living adult would.

There are five categories. Financial activity. Digital activity. Official records. Relational contact. Physical possessions.

Financial activity means bank accounts, credit cards, ATM withdrawals, loan payments, tax filings. A 52-year-old woman who runs three businesses generates daily financial activity. By the time MSP took over the case in August 2022, Dee had not generated a single transaction in 16 months.

Digital activity includes cell phone signal data, location data, social media, email, and web searches. Dee’s phone had gone silent at the Munger Road property at the end of April 2021 and never reappeared.

Official records mean healthcare claims, prescription refills, DMV transactions, voter activity, passport use. The state of Michigan, the federal government, and the systems they share data with had no record of Dee Warner doing anything that required identification.

Relational contact means calls, texts, letters, visits, and messages relayed through other people. A woman who talked to her son every day, her oldest friend almost daily, her daughter most days, and her brother regularly had not been in touch with any of them.

Physical possessions mean the things a living person uses to live. Her purse, her wallet, her ID, her clothes, her car. Everything that Dee Warner needed to be Dee Warner anywhere else was still in the house.

Detective Lieutenant Daniel Drewyor walked a Lenawee County probate judge through those five buckets in the summer of 2023. The family had filed a petition asking the court to declare Dee legally dead. They needed the declaration to access her estate, settle questions about her businesses, and give Angalena a clear legal path forward. Drewyor laid out, category by category, what Dee Warner had not done in 28 months.

On March 11, 2024, Lenawee County Probate Judge Catherine Sala declared Dee Ann Warner legally dead. By then, Dale Warner had already been in jail for three and a half months.

The Tank

Michigan State Police arrested Dale John Warner on the morning of November 22, 2023, at the Munger Road property, while the legal-death petition was still working its way through the courts. He was 55 years old. He was charged with open murder ( a Michigan-specific charge that allows a jury to decide between first-degree and second-degree murder at trial) and with tampering with evidence. He pleaded not guilty at his arraignment. Bond was set at $20 million. He did not post it.

The arrest came two and a half years after Dee disappeared. The body had not been found.

Filing open murder charges without a corpse is a gamble. The prosecutor has to believe, before the body is found, that the circumstantial evidence will convince a jury beyond a reasonable doubt that a homicide happened and that the defendant did it. Lenawee County Prosecutor Jacqueline Wyse made that bet on the strength of what Drewyor and the MSP task force had built across 16 months of reinvestigation. Phone records. Surveillance footage. Financial records. Witness statements were taken late, but thoroughly. The 2,100 location checks. The escape plan. The Saturday timeline. The Sunday body camera. The empty buckets.

Investigators had been searching for Dee since the spring of 2021. Cadaver dogs had walked the Munger Road property. Ground-penetrating radar had been run across the fields. Drainage culverts and bodies of water along M-50 had been searched. A marsh near the Warner farm had been searched in March 2024, the day after Dee was declared legally dead. Nothing.

The break came from inside Dale’s own digital records.

When MSP investigators pulled Dale’s iPad after his arrest, they found a search history entry dated May 5, 2021, ten days after Dee’s disappearance. It read: “What to do with a 1000-gallon propane tank?” Investigators also found searches for chemical cremation and liquid cremation.

No propane tanks on the Warner farms needed to be disposed of in May 2021. There was, however, an anhydrous ammonia tank, a 1,000-gallon mobile tank used for liquid fertilizer, that did not match any of the working containers in active use at the property. Anhydrous tanks are heavy, sealed at both ends, and welded shut at the seams. They are designed to hold a chemical that will kill a human being on contact. They are also large enough to hold a body.

Investigators went back through the property’s surveillance footage from April 25, 2021. The earlier review had not focused on the spray barn or the equipment yard. This time, they did.

They found Dale on camera early in the morning, before sunrise, retrieving an angle grinder and at least one cutting disc from the shop. They found him operating the JCB front-loader near the house. They found him moving an anhydrous tank. Later, after Dee’s children began arriving at the property looking for their mother, they found him operating equipment in the spray barn.

The welding-supply purchase records corroborated the footage. Dale had gathered the equipment he would need to cut metal and to weld it back together on the morning his wife disappeared.

In June 2024, MSP prepared a new search warrant for a property on Paragon Road in Tipton, several miles from the Munger Road house. Weeks after Dee’s disappearance, Parker Hardy had noticed a rusty anhydrous tank stored inside the spray barn. It was unusual, he thought, for a tank kept indoors.

The search warrant was executed on August 16, 2024. MSP was joined by Homeland Security, the FBI, and the Lenawee County Sheriff’s Office. They found the tank in a storage building on the Paragon Road site. It was tagged “out of service” and “do not fill.” Both ends had been welded shut. The welds were not factory welds. There was no reason for them to be there.

Investigators ran an X-ray on the tank before opening it. The X-ray showed something solid. They then inserted a camera through a small opening cut into the tank. The camera image showed a tarp. Inside the tarp was the body of Dee Ann Warner.

She was wearing pajamas. She was wrapped in blue tarps with her arms and legs bound with duct tape. The medical examiner’s findings indicated that she had been strangled. She had also suffered blunt-force trauma to her head and face. Toxicology testing found no oxycodone in her body, contradicting Dale's claims to investigators that Dee had been taking prescription painkillers for a migraine.

The body was formally identified through dental records and confirmed by DNA testing. Forensic testing matched Dale's fingerprints to prints found on the tank. Paint samples from the tank also matched paint on equipment at the Munger Road property.

The discovery was announced publicly on August 17, 2024. The family had been waiting for that announcement since the morning of April 25, 2021.

Four months earlier, with no body in hand and Dee’s death newly declared in probate court, the family had already held a celebration of life. On April 20, 2024, they gathered at Hardy Farms and blessed an empty gravestone they had set in the family plot at Franklin Township Cemetery. After the body was recovered in August, Dee’s remains were laid to rest beneath that stone, beside her parents.

Why He Staged Her as Missing

In the early days after Dee’s disappearance, her sister-in-law Shelley Hardy briefly worried that Dee might have killed herself. She told other family members that Dee had been under tremendous stress. The marriage had been hard. The businesses had been hard. Maybe Dee had reached the end of what she could hold. Maybe she had walked out into a field somewhere, or driven to a body of water, and taken herself out of her own life.

But she knew that Dee had a plan. She was going to leave her marriage, sell her trucking business, and move to a lakehouse down the road. She had told her daughters, her son, and her closest friends what she was going to do. The shell-of-herself exhaustion the family had seen on Saturday afternoon was not depression. It was the fatigue of wrestling with what to do with her life and deciding to change it.

Shelley’s worry surfaced on its own, a transient hypothesis to explain the absence of a 52-year-old woman whose disappearance did not make sense. Dale never claimed Dee was suicidal. But Dale had planted some seeds of emotional instability by hinting, through his tale of Dee’s “pills,” of possible substance abuse problems. So why did Dale Warner hide Dee in a tank instead of staging a suicide?

Research on crime-scene staging gives us a starting point. About 8 percent of homicides involve some form of staging, and the strongest predictor is a close personal relationship between the offender and the victim. Husbands and boyfriends stage scenes far more often than strangers do.

But staging is only one of the things killers do to avoid getting caught. Researchers have spent more than a decade building out a broader concept called detection avoidance, i.e., anything an offender does to hide, destroy, or manipulate evidence. Staging the scene is one tactic. So is fabricating an alibi, discrediting the victim, coaching witnesses, hiding the body, or selling the story that the victim simply walked away.

A 2024 study of 100 intimate-partner femicides found that 43 percent involved some form of detection avoidance. And researchers have made an important conceptual move: detection avoidance is not something a killer does after the fact. It is a continuation of the same controlling behavior that shaped the relationship. The man who controlled where his wife went, what she said, and who she saw also controls the story of her death.

The FBI’s 2017 article on no-body homicide cases puts it more bluntly: “Someone creating the illusion of a person voluntarily missing requires extra effort, which investigators should view as an element of staging.”

So why concealment over suicide?

Five things explain the choice.

Cause of death. A staged suicide only works if the manner of death looks plausibly self-inflicted. The list of options is short: hanging, gunshot, overdose, jumping, or sometimes a single sharp injury to the wrist or throat. Strangulation by another person, blunt-force trauma to the head and face, defensive wounds, and most patterns of multiple-mechanism violence are not survivable as suicide stories. Dee was strangled and beaten on the head and face. That combination cannot be staged as a suicide. Once the killing produces a body that an autopsy will read as homicide, the only way to keep the homicide hidden is to keep the body hidden.

Forensic risk. A staged suicide produces a body that gets a full autopsy. Petechiae in the eyes. A fractured hyoid bone in the neck. Defensive wounds on the hands and arms. Ligature marks that don’t line up with the story. Missing toxins. Scene details that don’t match the body. A competent medical examiner can detect all of it. A body sealed inside a welded tank produces no autopsy at all unless someone finds the tank and opens it. From a pure exposure standpoint, hiding the body is the lower-risk play.

Time. A suicide forces authorities to make an immediate ruling. A disappearance does not. Disappearances stay ambiguous, and ambiguity is something a smart killer can manage for years. Memories fade. Witnesses move. Phone records fall outside the retention window. Detectives retire or rotate to other cases. The FBI’s 2017 article names this directly: offenders believe that “the longer a victim is presumed missing and not found, the easier they remove themselves from culpability.” Dee Warner was missing for two years and seven months before Dale was arrested, and three years and almost four months before her body was found. That gap was not an accident. It was the point. Disappearance, not a staged suicide, gave Dale those years.

Resources. Hiding a body well takes property, time, and equipment that most killers don’t have. Dale had all three. He had 1,500 acres of farmland. He had heavy machinery, welding gear, decommissioned anhydrous tanks, and barns no one was checking. Most men who kill their wives don’t have any of that. They live in apartments and rented houses, where the only available staging is whatever they can do with the scene in front of them. Dale had the rural advantage, and he used it.

Believability. A staged suicide requires the victim to look believable as suicidal. A disappearance only requires the victim to look believably capable of leaving. Dee was actively planning a divorce, running a thriving company, and deeply involved in her children’s lives. Nothing about her looked suicidal. But the family’s perception of her as feisty and capable of walking out in anger gave Dale enough material to sell the disappearance story. The suicide story would have required him to invent a mental-health history that didn’t exist. The disappearance story did not.

Women living in long-term coercive control can be seen by their families as more fragile than they really are. The visible strain of being controlled takes its toll, while the cause of that strain remains out of sight. It can also make it easier for the perpetrator to spin a mental health story.

In my database of 164 homicides staged to look like suicide, the perpetrator claimed the victim was depressed in roughly 53 percent of cases. Family members corroborated those claims in only about 3 percent.

For investigators and the families I work with, the lesson is that staging effects can show up even when the offender hasn't staged anything. The Warner case is unusual on that point. In most staged-suicide cases, the perpetrator plants the depression narrative himself, and a family member who didn't know better repeats it. Dale planted nothing. The suicide hypothesis surfaced anyway, briefly, because someone who loved Dee reached for it on her own. That doesn't mean Dale got the benefit of a family-supplied story; he didn't, and the family corrected course quickly. But it shows how coercive control can leave families ready to imagine suicide for women who were never suicidal, even with no help from the man who killed them.

Adrian, Michigan

Dale Warner’s trial began on February 12, 2026, in the Lenawee County Circuit Court in Adrian. The case was People of the State of Michigan v. Dale John Warner.

The trial lasted five weeks. The state called 35 witnesses across 12 days of testimony. One by one, the family's witnesses took the stand. The Bock children, Amy Alexander, Stacey Brodie, Dustin Lolley, every person who had spent four years building the case for what had really happened to Dee now told a jury under oath.

The defense called three witnesses. Dale did not testify. The jury, seven men and five women, deliberated for several hours across two days. On the morning of March 10, 2026, they found Dale Warner guilty of second-degree murder. Guilty of tampering with evidence.

The state had asked for first-degree.

The verdict turned on a question of timing. Michigan's first-degree murder statute requires premeditation and deliberation, and the prosecution's strongest evidence of planning came after Dee was already dead. The iPad search about the disposal of a 1,000-gallon propane tank was dated May 5, 2021, ten days after Dee disappeared. The welding supplies on the surveillance footage were gathered on the morning of April 25, hours after the killing. Both belonged to the concealment phase, not the planning phase.

The jury chose the lesser charge. What the state had proved, they decided, was a killing that emerged from a long pattern of control and culminated on the night Dee told her husband she was leaving him. Not a cold blueprint executed on a chosen day. A culminating act inside a coercive structure.

Outside the courthouse on the afternoon of March 10, 2026, Gregg Hardy spoke to reporters. He thanked the prosecution. He thanked the Michigan State Police. He said he was grateful. He said that “Justice for Dee” now felt like Victory for Dee. He also said he was disappointed that the verdict was not first-degree.

“He is an atrocious piece of human trash, in my opinion,” Gregg said about his sister’s killer. “A debris. However you like to say it. No one should ever consider doing that to a human being, let alone the mother of your child or your wife.”

Sentencing was set for May 7, 2026.

For the Families Who Already Know

The hardest part of the Dee Warner case for the people who loved her was not the not-knowing. It was the knowing without being able to make anyone else know.

The Hardy and Bock family understood, by the afternoon of April 25, 2021, that Dee had not walked away. They were the first to know and the last to need convincing. The two and a half years between that Sunday afternoon and Dale Warner’s arrest were spent moving the sheriff’s office, the prosecutor, and the public to where the family had been since the beginning.

Most families in this position do not move the institution. The case remains a missing-person case. The investigation drifts, the years accumulate, and the narrative the offender supplied on day one becomes, over time, the narrative of record.

The reason the Warner case turned out differently is that the Hardy-Bock family did, by instinct, what researchers and prosecutors who work no-body and intimate-partner cases recommend. They organized. They documented. They escalated.

Here is a framework for the families who already know what happened to their loved one and need to make the people in authority know it, too.

Document the baseline. Investigators and prosecutors need to see, in concrete detail, what the missing person’s normal life looked like. Routines, daily habits, work patterns, parenting rhythms, photographs, and witness statements from people who saw them regularly. The point is to make the absence read as out of character at first glance.

Document the empty buckets. Once the missing person has been gone for more than a few days, families should begin documenting absences in the five categories investigators will eventually need: financial activity, digital activity, official records, relational contact, and physical possessions. Each empty bucket is independently weak. Together they make the case.

Document the suspect’s behavior. Detection-avoidance research has shown that perpetrators often leak their plans before the homicide. Comments about how they would conceal a body. Hypothetical questions. Suggestions to friends or family that the victim was unstable, depressed, or suicidal. Families should write down anything the suspect said in the months before the disappearance that now reads differently, and ask others to do the same.

What he says after she's gone matters too. A timeline that doesn't hold up. A story that changes from one telling to the next. Sudden purchases that don't fit with anything else going on.

Take action. Register the case with NamUs, the National Missing and Unidentified Persons System, within the first two weeks. Send formal data-preservation requests to cell carriers, email providers, social media platforms, and cloud storage services. Push for multi-agency involvement when the local agency is stalling; Dee’s family played a huge role in the August 2022 transfer of the case to the Michigan State Police.

Consult specialists. Tad DiBiase consults with families and agencies on no-body homicide cases. Domestic Violence Death Review Teams exist in most U.S. states. Project Cold Case provides advocacy to families of unsolved homicide victims and long-term missing persons where foul play is suspected.

Families who suspect a homicide should think about their own safety before they think about evidence. If the suspect is still in the family’s social or geographic orbit, documentation efforts should be coordinated with an attorney, kept off shared devices, and stored outside the home.

Dee Ann Hardy is buried at Franklin Township Cemetery in Tipton, Michigan, beside her parents, Raynor and Wanda. The gravestone reads “Dee Ann, daughter of Raynor and Wanda Hardy,” followed by the names of her five children. It does not carry the name Warner.

* * *

As always, thank you for reading this week’s issue of The Mind Detective. If you enjoy it, please pass it along to one true-crime-following friend. See you next week!

References

Bonny, E., Almond, L., & Woolnough, P. (2016). Adult missing persons: Can an investigative framework be generated using behavioural themes? Journal of Investigative Psychology and Offender Profiling, 13(3), 296–312. https://doi.org/10.1002/jip.1459

Campbell, J. C., Webster, D., Koziol-McLain, J., Block, C., Campbell, D., Curry, M. A., Gary, F., Glass, N., McFarlane, J., Sachs, C., Sharps, P., Ulrich, Y., Wilt, S. A., Manganello, J., Xu, X., Schollenberger, J., Frye, V., & Laughon, K. (2003). Risk factors for femicide in abusive relationships: Results from a multisite case control study. American Journal of Public Health, 93(7), 1089–1097. https://doi.org/10.2105/AJPH.93.7.1089

DiBiase, T. A. (2024). No-body homicide cases: A practical guide to investigating, prosecuting, and winning cases when the victim is missing (2nd ed.). CRC Press / Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781032618098

Ferguson, C., & McLachlan, F. (2023). Continuing coercive control after intimate partner femicide: The role of detection avoidance and concealment. Feminist Criminology, 18(5), 561–584. https://doi.org/10.1177/15570851231189531

McLachlan, F., & Ferguson, C. (2024). Rates and features of detection avoidance in intimate partner femicide in Australia. Homicide Studies. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1177/10887679241233980

Monckton Smith, J. (2020). Intimate partner femicide: Using Foucauldian analysis to track an eight-stage progression to homicide. Violence Against Women, 26(11), 1267–1285. https://doi.org/10.1177/1077801219863876

Schlesinger, L. B., Gardenier, A., Jarvis, J., & Sheehan-Cook, J. (2014). Crime scene staging in homicide. Journal of Police and Criminal Psychology, 29(1), 44–51. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11896-012-9114-6

Whibley, J., Newiss, G., & Collie, C. J. R. (2023). Cause of death in fatal missing person cases in England and Wales. International Journal of Police Science & Management, 25(4), 422–432. https://doi.org/10.1177/14613557231182049

Yoder, M. (2017, September 20). No-body homicide cases: A practical approach. FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin. https://leb.fbi.gov/articles/featured-articles/no-body-homicide-cases-a-practical-approach

Legal Authority

People v. Scott, 176 Cal. App. 2d 458 (Cal. Ct. App. 1959).